Do you really want a stranger remixing your record?

Well, here we are at the end of 2026, and the AI "thing" is in full swing. Deezer says it now gets around 90,000 fully AI-made uploads a day. On every social platform there are droves of AI "artists" (quotey fingers) insisting they're real artists, while the other side, the "manual music makers" as I've heard us called, fight back and say writing a prompt is not a substitute for talent.
The newest development is Spotify's AI covers and remixes tool, which looks set to arrive in early 2027. On 20 October, Believe and TuneCore artists were told they can opt in, so loads of indie artists will soon have to answer yes or no. Interestingly, you can still say no even if your label has signed up, and remix plays are supposed to pay the original rights holders.
About a decade ago I was sitting in a café in Romania, at the time a pretty Wild West sort of place musically, when I froze in disbelief. A dance version of Steeleye Span's All Around My Hat was playing. How could this 1970s folk song, which I remembered from my mum's record collection (mostly because of its very weird album cover, which I was obsessed with), be a dance tune?! So the concept is far from new.
But now everything is fair game. If you opt in.
The main answer to the outrage is simple: don't opt in, and you won't be remixed by some rando. But will you miss out? Millions of terrible, heinous versions will appear legitimately on the platform, and some of them will inevitably become hits. In theory, your mum could click a button, make a remix and have a hit. There will always be outliers, and someone somewhere will make money, while most people get the trickle of pennies we're all used to by now.
Can we learn anything from AI music?
Perhaps, and I hate to admit it. Past the swishiness, tone and delivery (every song sounds like the Nickelback version of whatever genre it is, which is a testament to Nickelback cracking the code of mass appeal, if you ask me), AI tunes have a certain "finished" sound. They're in time and in tune, some attention has been paid to arrangement, and in some cases they actually give off a vibe of professionalism that a lot of DIY tracks lack.
That's the bit worth thinking about. AI has quietly set a new baseline. When a listener's feed is full of tracks that at least sound polished, a rough home mix doesn't sound charmingly raw anymore, it just sounds unfinished. The bar for "sounds like a proper record" hasn't dropped, it's gone up.
The entire Nashville songwriting playbook has been fed into the algorithm, after all. To be fair, we humans are also a product of everything we've ever listened to, thrown in a blender, filtered through our memories and somehow re-emerging in our own art. The difference is that we bring taste, personality and a reason for making the thing in the first place.
In time, slop will become part of mainstream music whether we like it or not, but that doesn't really matter. As many have said, human craftsmanship in every field will become a premium thing, as it should be. We've been in a cycle of devaluation for a long time, and perhaps this will be the catalyst for movement in the opposite direction.
The same story with tools
AI plugins are the hot thing this week, and like everything new, they're a double-edged sword. Democratising something gives far more people access, but the variance in quality gets much wider and generally worse. I like the idea of being able to build tools that help with certain workflows, but I'm not putting the production machine that earns me a living at the mercy of a vibe-coded plugin or DAW any time soon. Imagine someone making one of these becomes successful with zero support structure in place. It's bad enough with the big manufacturers: a beta update I was testing for a major company made one of my interfaces unusable for a month.
So, would I opt in?
ME? I don’t know! And only you can make that decision for yourself. If you're an indie artist releasing music in 2027,here's what I'd focus on:
Decide on the remix question based on what your music means to you, not fear of missing out.
Then put your energy into the things AI can't do: write songs with a point of view, commit performances with personality and emotion, and maybe increase our focus on making records that are properly finished, sound like real records and are better than ever.
That's what's going to stand out.
Thanks for reading, as ever and if you need help taking your work to the next level and to truly sound like a record please reach out and let's have a conversation - it costs nothing and I can genuinely make your music stand out.



Comments